-
Q. Which car is better- automatic or manual?
26.8K Views Follow Question Add Answer140 Answers
Pradipta | 4 years ago8 ReplyBasically in a manual transmission it depends on the driver , full control I with the driver and manual transmission is always reliable and for spprty and thrilling experience manual is awesome . Mileage to goes good with manual transmission . But in automatic transmission it becomes boring Just press the accelerator and the car is going on its own ,the driver has just no control over the car , automatic transmission is a bit moddy If you go on a long drive then I would prefer manual transmission and also for thrilling experience
Zeeshan | 4 years ago8 ReplyAutomatic cars only benefit you if you often go for long drives(>100 km) and that too 4 or 5 times a month.Also automatic car is better for old aged and handicaped people.Since automatic cars have a higher price than the manual onea therefore it is just a wastage of money.Manual gearbox is way too better in performance espacially of you are driving on terrans and hilly roads.S
Updates | 5 years ago8 ReplyManual has manual mood... automatic is however a moody car.. you cannot make a control over pickup amd pressure in automatic car. For sporty and thrilling drive you cannot choose automatic car. But it is good in traffic conditions in city. As it is easier to drive during rush hours.
Jo | 5 years ago1 ReplyManual is always better.But if it is a CVT 7 speed as in a volkswagon with dsg gearbox and manual tiptronic nothing like that.amt and ags are not better performers.CVT in s Toyota or Camry is confusing.merc has a 9 speed automatic which is also nice
Rishi | 4 years ago1 ReplyIt completely depends upon you on which type of vehicle you will be comfortable to drive. for me, Manual is the best as if a person knows how to drive a car which is based on manual transmission, he can drive any kind of a car
Madhav | 4 years ago4 ReplyI would suggest to go for manual. In traffic AM, AT or CVT are much better compared to Manual. I personally prefer Manual. There are 3-4 options available AT, Atomatic, CVT. All are good.... with added money
Abir | 5 years ago3 ReplyI also have the same question in my mind. So I did some research on it and also asked few person who have automobile knowledge... as per that nowadays Automatic transmission are much much better... Maruti and Hyundai both using some machinery which is low maintenance and high performance. I gathered my knowledge after buying my car otherwise I would also bought a AMT version
Meharban | 4 years ago0 ReplyThat's purely depends on your usage. City dirvign bumper to bumper traffic buy auto. Now dayas AMT is also available with affordable price if usage is 4-5 km every day then go for Manual transmission
Himanshu | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic if you want to go easy on yourself when you have to face bumper to bumper traffic on your daily commute , else manual car should not be a problem also manual offers more engaging drive.
Jaskirat | 4 years ago0 ReplyIn india automatic comes in high end cars priced above 10 lac , the automatic transmission in cars below 10 lac is not ATM transmission it's , really poor quality . so my choice depends on my budget .
Yogi Ahir | 5 years ago1 ReplyThe automatic is always hassle free, easy to drive, but drills a hole in your pockets for mileage. The manual gives better economy than the automatic, and a manual can be easy to maintain.
CHIRAGG | 5 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic may prove to be good if you travel in heavy traffic areas but manual may be good if you love to drive in a sporty manner and manual will be good for long drives
Rohan | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual is more better than automatic because you won't be able to know when to change the gears when to not... it's like a car Scuty...u should always go for manual... driving a manual car is like gaining much experience than automatic
Dipendra | 4 years ago0 ReplyFun to drive is manual variants but if you live in metropolitan cities and hav to face lot of traffic then go for automatic as its reliable in bumper to bumper traffic and doesnt harm your clutch plate or any other parts.
Balakrishnan | 5 years ago1 ReplyIt depends on your requirement. If you are comfortable with changing gears, manual is for you. If you fumble while changing gears go for automatic.
Mayank | 5 years ago0 ReplyDepends upon your driving needs. If you drive in extreme congested conditions then go for the automatic. Else go for the manual.
Estudio | 5 years ago0 ReplyI dependsIf you want to be furious driving then manual.If you want to ride normally like no power in car then auto.
Roy | 5 years ago2 ReplyDepends on your daily usage. If you drive more than 50 kms every day, go for diesel. If under that go for petrol.
Yashwardhan | 6 years ago4 ReplyIt's simple . If you like to drive and want to have some amazing driving fun, then ofcourse go for a manual. but if you just want to go from point A to point B , then surely go with an automatic.
Parshuram | 6 years ago0 ReplyBoth systems are good depending on it`s need. In big cities that are hugely crowded, automatic transmission is convenient but in other areas,manual system works better. p.gautampurkar
Nikhil | 2 years ago0 ReplyBasically in a manual transmission it depends on the driver full control I with the driver and manual transmission is always reliable and for support and thrilling ...
Incredibie | 4 years ago0 ReplyIn my knowledge manual is better than automatic. For more knowledge you should motorOctane channel in YouTube.
Abhijit | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual in terms of better fuel eff + lesser complications in maintenance
Alby | 4 years ago0 ReplyFor indian roads as per the traffic status amt s better option
KartikeySharmaIndoria | 2 years ago0 ReplyFor Check full potential of car, then you should go for Manual... and if a person loose his enthusiasm for driving then he should buy automatic
Sudarshan | 2 years ago0 ReplyManual any day....if one is willing to bear the constant shifting of gears in traffic....we control manual cars whereas auto cars control us...
Varun | 5 years ago0 ReplyIn city traffic go for automatic,otherwise go for manual
Arun | 6 years ago2 ReplySenior citizen, city with plain roads, females, senior executive can go for automatic. Else performance and control of mannual is always better
Akash | 5 years ago0 ReplyLike your useif you are driving in a city automatic is good
Raghavendra | 6 years ago0 ReplyIf you live in a big city with traffic, you can go for automatic eyes closed. I'm realizing the same everytime I get in a traffic jam.
Srinivas | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic but if there is CVT version, the AGS is no good
Jagjeet | 4 years ago0 ReplyIf anyone has questions, you can ask anything
Suraj | 5 years ago0 ReplyAutimatic is 1 Lakh expensive than the Manual, and as per my individual view, Manual car is its own fun to drive than the AMT car.
Sonu | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual is always better as it gives more mileage then automatic
B | 5 years ago1 ReplyI have automatic and it's convenient ride
Monika | 4 years ago0 ReplyDepends on your need. I prefer Manual
Satyanarayan | 5 years ago0 ReplyCity run- Automatic, otherwise Manual
Viswanath | 4 years ago1 ReplyAutomatic if you are looking for daily commute in city
PriyankAgarwal | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual as u will get more milage
Sarileru | 4 years ago0 Reply@ Ankit | Automatic is fun and relaxing
Automatic is best should ibuy
Matt | 4 years ago0 ReplyDepends on your comfort and Utility
Asif | 5 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic car... If you are not an experienced driver.
Kiran | 3 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic is best option
Preston | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual The Masterclass
Libin | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual i like manual
Ankit | 4 years ago1 ReplyAutomatic is fun and relaxing
रवि_कुमार_झा | 5 years ago0 Replyमैनुअल
Vishal | 5 years ago0 ReplyFor passion manual
Paveesh | 3 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic is the best. Easy to drive .
Punit | 3 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic for metro cities
Anushrey | 4 years ago0 ReplyIf you are a master you should prefer manual.
Sathya | 5 years ago0 ReplySwift manual
Siddhanta | 4 years ago0 ReplyFor City ride automatic is best..
Parasengineer | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic.
Akhil | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Vedant | 5 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Ramesh | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Dnyaneshwar | 5 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Rabi | 5 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
PrashantYadav | 5 years ago0 Reply@ Abir | I also have the same question in my mind. So I did some research on it and also asked few person who have automobile knowledge... as per that nowadays Automatic transmission are much much better... Maruti and Hyundai both using some machinery which is low maintenance and high performance. I gathered my knowledge after buying my car otherwise I would also bought a AMT version
Nice...
Vishal | 3 years ago0 ReplyManual
Manish 7 Padhi | 3 years ago1 ReplyManual
Kumar | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Imna | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Amit | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
ZubairPeelippuram | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
Niranjan | 3 years ago1 ReplyManual
Ajay | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Arjun | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Mohammad | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Monika | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Umer | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Kunal | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Yogesh | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Shreeram | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
Gourav | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
Ramesh | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
Sandeep | 4 years ago0 ReplyYes
Irfan | 4 years ago0 ReplyYas
SimanchalamBhoi | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Gilakamsetty | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Bipul | 5 years ago1 ReplyBoth are good. Automatic transmission will benefit you with hassle free gear shifting.
Sarileru | 4 years ago0 Reply@ jo | Manual is always better.But if it is a CVT 7 speed as in a volkswagon with dsg gearbox and manual tiptronic nothing like that.amt and ags are not better performers.CVT in s Toyota or Camry is confusing.merc has a 9 speed automatic which is also nice
Thank you
Muktar | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
M | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Aryan | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Mohd | 3 years ago0 ReplyManual
Arun | 3 years ago0 ReplyManual
Sahil | 3 years ago0 ReplyManual
Sukh | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Madhav | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Nitesh | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
GT TSI | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Lucky | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Vedant | 4 years ago0 ReplyMANUAL
Navin | 4 years ago0 ReplyMANUAL
Dr. Alok Semwal | 4 years ago0 ReplyMaual
Jeren | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual is good for everyday use
Karan | 6 years ago1 ReplyAutomatic is far better than manual there is no pain in traffic and smooth ride.
Sudhir | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Cr7 | 4 years ago1 ReplyManual
Raghvendra | 6 years ago0 ReplyIn my opinion Manual is good Coz it gives the real Pleasure of driving.
Yatin | 5 years ago1 ReplyBest option today while driving in city is only automatic transmission
IndianMarbleCompany | 3 years ago0 ReplyManual,AMT
Parshuram | 6 years ago0 ReplyManual gear , of course , should be preferred over automatic1gear,.
IndianMarbleCompany | 3 years ago0 ReplyBoth
Jegan | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
NirmalMalana | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Vinayak | 5 years ago0 ReplyIf u drive mostly in traffic then auto otherwise manual
Dharmveer | 4 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Nirmal | 4 years ago0 ReplyManual
Veda | 2 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic means fuel ,cng plus petrol
Anant | 5 years ago1 ReplyAutomatic will be more comfortable.
Shri | 6 years ago0 ReplyFrom my point of view manual is good
Veda | 2 years ago0 ReplyMaruti ertiga cng petrol price
Amulya | 6 years ago0 ReplyManual transmission is best.
Hemant | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
Shubham | 5 years ago1 ReplyAutomatic transmission
Rutu | 6 years ago1 ReplyAutomatic is better
Raju | 6 years ago0 ReplyManual is good
PramodYadav | 1 year ago0 ReplyAutomatic
AjayNahariya | 2 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
PVRajeevMenon | 2 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Elvisstuart | 2 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Thulasi | 5 years ago0 ReplyAutomatic
Sujeet | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
Pratik | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
ChetanDasari | 1 year ago0 ReplyManual
SunilPhilip | 1 year ago0 ReplyManuel
SmarthBishnoi | 1 year ago0 ReplyManual
SaravanaKumar | 2 years ago0 ReplyManual
Machanthira | 2 years ago0 ReplyManual
Animesh | 2 years ago0 ReplyManual
GA | 2 years ago0 ReplyManual
Asif | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
Kabir | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
Selva | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
Jvrsanjay | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
Ankur | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
KURNAWALVINOD | 5 years ago0 ReplyManual
Add your Answer
Incorrect word(s) in your text, please rectify Submit Answer
From The Swift 2014-2021 Community
-
Q. Can I fit CNG in LXI (0) from Company itself and w ...
Asked by Regimon Joseph
13 Answers
-
Q. Does Swift lxi has abs?
Asked by Manoj Kumar
4 Answers
-
Q. Does swift have automatic gear?
Asked by Xavier Marshalfernandes
56 Answers
-
Q. I want to buy Swift Zxi variant i.e 3rd petrol var ...
Asked by Kavin Kumar
3 Answers
-
Q. Seating capacity of swift?
Asked by Data Bank
3 Answers
-
Q. I wish to purchase automatic car.which one is the ...
Asked by Kaushal Khullar
8 Answers
-
Q. Want to compare mid and top model? Please help . - ...
Asked by Angalamman Traders
2 Answers
-
Q. How many km ride is must for swift vdi per month?
Asked by Uzma Arshad
3 Answers
-
Q. Does swift have central lock and automatic window?
Asked by Archana Singh
2 Answers
-
Q. Can we run swift vehicle at high speed after compl ...
Asked by Arjun Pk
2 Answers
Related Questions
Q. My daily drive is 100km. Which car will best for me in terms of mileage, comfort and security?
6.8K Views 11 AnswersQ. Which car should I buy under 8 lakh with good built quality, good average and safety?
60.3K Views 132 Answers
Have a question in mind? 1 Lakh+ answers from Owners & Experts
Get Answers from Experts & Owners
- Interact with community
- Become a Top Contributor
More Cars in Same budget
-
Maruti S-Presso
Rs. 4.26 Lakh
-
Maruti Ignis
Rs. 5.49 Lakh
-
Renault Kiger
Rs. 5.99 Lakh
-
Tata Tiago
Rs. 4.99 Lakh
Choose Different Budget
Trending Maruti Cars
-
Maruti Dzire
Rs. 6.79 Lakh
-
Maruti Swift
Rs. 6.49 Lakh
-
Maruti Ertiga
Rs. 8.69 Lakh
-
Maruti Brezza
Rs. 8.34 Lakh
-
Maruti FRONX
Rs. 7.51 Lakh
Thanks for reporting this. The reported answer will be shortly removed from Zigwheels &
will be sent for moderation.
Choose your city
-
New Delhi
-
Bengaluru
-
Mumbai
-
Kolkata
-
Chennai
-
Pune
-
Hyderabad
-
Ahmedabad
-
Patna
Thank you! Your question has been submitted and is under moderartion.
You will receive all communications on :
Say a Car or a Bike Name
Cancel