MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch

MG Comet EV Price starts at Rs. 6.99 Lakh which is Rs. 86,900 costlier than base model of Tata Punch priced at Rs. 6.12 Lakh. The claimed mileage of Tata Punch (Petrol Model) is 18.8 Kmpl. In technical specifications, Tata Punch (Top Model) is powered by 1199 cc engine. The Comparison MG Comet EV 100 Year Limited Edition vs Tata Punch Creative Plus S Camo AMT can be described on the basis of price and specifications.

Comet EV vs Punch

Key Highlights Comet EV 100 Year Limited EditionPunch Creative Plus S Camo AMT
Engine Type ... 1.2 l Revotron
Motor Power 41.42 kW ...
Max Power 41.42bhp 87bhp@6000rpm
Range 230 km/charge ...
Charging Time 7.5KW 3.5H(0-100%) ...
Top Speed ... 150 Km/h
Mileage (ARAI) ... 18.8 Kmpl
  1. Home ›
  2. New Cars ›
  3. Compare Cars ›
  4. MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch

Comet EV vs Punch Key Highlights

Basic Info MG Motor Comet EV 100 Year Limited EditionTata Punch Creative Plus S Camo AMT
Rating
96 reviews
293 reviews
Brand Name MG Motor Tata
Ex-Showroom Price Rs. 9.64 Lakh Get On-Road Price Rs. 10.14 Lakh Get On-Road Price
Engine Displacement ... 1199 cc
Body Type HatchbackAll Hatchback Cars SUVAll SUV Cars
Max Power 41.42bhp 87bhp@6000rpm
No Of Cylinders ... 3
Transmission Automatic Automatic
Gearbox 1-Speed 5-Speed AMT
Drive Type RWD FWD
Colors
MG Motor Comet EV Colors
Tata Punch Colors
Fuel Type Electric(Battery) Petrol
Mileage (ARAI) ... 18.8 Kmpl
Tyre Size 145/70 R12 195/60 R16
Steering Mounted Audio Control Yes Yes
Cruise Control ... Yes
Airbags Driver and Passenger Driver and Passenger
EMI
Rs. 18,664 @ 10.5% (60 months)
Rs. 19,633 @ 10.5% (60 months)
Servicing Cost ...
Rs. 23,561 / 5 years
Insurance Rs. 39,609 Comet EV Insurance Rs. 50,106 Punch Insurance
Brochure
Download Brochure
Download Brochure

Engine Type
...
1.2 l Revotron
Motor Power
41.42 kW
...
Engine Displacement
...
1199 cc
Battery Capacity
17.3 kWh
...
Motor Type
Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor
...
Max Power
41.42bhp
87bhp@6000rpm
Range
230 km/charge
...
Max Torque
110Nm
115Nm@3150-3350rpm
Emission Norm Compliance
ZEV
BS VI 2.0
No Of Cylinders
...
3
Transmission
Automatic
Automatic
Gearbox
1-Speed
5-Speed AMT
Valves Per Cylinder
4
Drive Type
RWD
FWD
Charging Time
7.5KW 3.5H(0-100%)
...
Fast Charging
...
Charging Port
CCS-II
...

Fuel Type
Electric(Battery)
Petrol
Fuel Capacity
...
37 Liters
Top Speed
...
150 Km/h
Mileage (ARAI)
...
18.8 Kmpl

Suspension Front
Suspension Rear
6
Brakes Front
Disc
Disc
Brakes Rear
Disc
Drum
Steering Type
Electric
Electric
Minimum Turning Radius
4.2 m
...
Tyre Size
145/70 R12
195/60 R16
Wheel Size
12
Tyre Type
Radial Tubeless
Radial Tubeless

Dual Tone Dashboard
...
Additional Interior Features
(Leatherette) Wrapped Steering Wheel,PVC Layering on door trim,Inside door handle with Chrome,100-Year Edition Theme PVC Seat Upholstery
Rear Flat Floor,Parcel Tray
Digital Cluster
Embedded LCD Scree
Air Conditioner
Digital Odometer
...
Seating Capacity
4
5
Doors
2
5

Alloy Wheels
...
Additional Exterior Features
Modern Parallel Steps LED Headlamp,Black Finish ORVMs,Dark Chrome Finish Comet Emblem,Black Finish Internet Inside Emblem,Customizable Lock Screen Wallpaper,Modern Parallel Steps LED Taillamp,Illuminated MG Logo,LED turn indicators on ORVMs,Outside door handle with Chrome,Body Coloured ORVM & Side Garnish,Aero Wiper (Boneless Wiper),Extended Horizon Front & Rear Connecting Lights,Turn Indicator Integrated DRL,100-Year Edition Emblem
A Pillar Black Tape
Rain Sensing Wiper
...
Roof Rails
...
Length*Width*Height
2974*1505*1640 mm3
3827*1742*1615 mm3
Wheelbase
2010 mm
2445 mm
Ground Clearance (Unladen)
...
187 mm

Connectivity
Android Auto, Apple CarPlay
...
Addtional Comfort Features
One Key Seat Turning mechanism for 2nd row entry (Co-Driver seat only),Creep Mode,0.5L Bottle Holder In Doors,Front Co-Driver Grab Handle,Widget Customization of Homescreen with Multiple Pages,Customisable Widget Color with 7 color palette for Homepage of Infotainment Screen,Headunit Theme Store with New EVERGREEN Theme,Driver & Co-Driver Vanity Mirror,Smart Start System,Digital Key with sharing function,Front 12V Power outlet,Voice Coands For Car Functions, AC On/off, Radio, Remaining Mileage,Quiet Mode, Etc,30+ Hinglish Voice Coands,Voice Coands For Weather, Cricket, Calculator, Clock, Date/day, Horoscope, Dictionary, News & Knowledge,Widget Customisation Of Homescreen With Multiple Pages,Customisable Lock Screen Wallpaper,Theme Store To Download Themes,Brightness Sync Function (For Infotainment And Cluster),Birthday Wish On Headunit (With Customisable Date Option),Charging Details On
Door, Wheel Arch & Sill cladding,IAC + ISS Technology,Xpress Cool
USB Charger
Front
Front & Rear
Central Control Armrest
...
With Storage
Luggage Hook and Net
Additional Entertainment Features
Bluetooth Music & Calling,Wireless Android Auto & Apple CarPlay,i-Smart with 55+ Connected car features
Wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay
Automatic Climate Control
Not Available
Available
One Touch Operating Power Windows
Driver's Window
Driver's Window
No of Speakers
2
4
AC
Rear AC Ducts
...
Heater
Power Steering
Steering Column
Tilt
Tilt
Steering Mounted Audio Control
Cruise Control
...
Power Windows ( Front / Rear )
...
Front and Rear
Adjustable Driver Seat
...
Heated Seat Front
Heated Seats Rear
Wireless Phone Charging
...
Subwoofer
Folding Rear Seat
50:50 Split
...
Height Adjustable Driver Seat
...
Engine Start Stop Button
Rear ACVents
...
Multifunction Steering Wheel
Tachometer
...
Rear Seat Centre Arm Rest
...
Voice assisted sunroof
...
Seat Belt Warning
Push Ignition
AM/FM Radio
Touch-screen Display
Speakers Front
Speakers Rear
...
Auto Rain Sensing Wipers
...
Follow me home headlamps
Adjustable Headlamps
...
Parking Sensors
Rear
Rear
Front Cupholders
Door Pockets
Front Door
Front & Rear Door
12V Power Outlets
Bottle Holder
Front Door
Front & Rear Door
Sunroof
...
Single Pane

Anti-Pinch Power Windows
...
Speed Sensing Auto Door Lock
...
ISOFIX Child Seat Mounts
Day/Night Rearview Mirror
Hill Assist
...
Impact Sensing Auto Door Unlock
...
Airbags
Driver and Passenger
Driver and Passenger
Anti-lock Braking System (ABS)
No of Airbags
2
2
Engine Immobilizer
Central Locking
Advance Safety Features
Driver & Co-Driver 3-point Seat Belt with Load Limiter,Rear seat belt - 3-point seat belt,Manual Day/Night IRVM,Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (Indirect),Electronic Parking Brake,Remote Central Locking,Find My Car,Vehicle Overspeed Alert With Customisable Speed Limit,IP67 Rated Battery
...
Global NCAP Safety Rating
...
5 Star
Global NCAP Child Safety Rating
...
4 Star
Rear Wash Wiper
...
Keyless Entry
Rear Defogger
...
Rear Camera
3
3

Over the Air (OTA) Updates
...
Smartwatch App
...
Live Location
...
Remote Immobiliser
...
Engine Start Alarm
...
Digital Car Key
...
Hinglish Voice Commands
...
ECall And ICall
...
Over Speeding Alert
...
Valet Mode
...
Remote Door Lock Unlock
...

Pros and Cons

  • Positives
  • Negatives
Tata Punch
  • The Punch is a good mix of a hatchback and an SUV. Impressive cabin quality
  • clever customization options make it even more appealing. New 10.25-inch touchscreen for 2024. Received a 5-star Global NCAP safety rating.
Tata Punch
  • No diesel engine option. The 1.2L engine lacks the punch for ease of use on highway or when fully loaded.

Is MG Comet EV Better Than Tata Punch?

64% users have chosen MG Comet EV over Tata Punch in a survey being conducted on zigwheels.com.
Apart from this survey a total of 691 users have also rated MG Comet EV and Tata Punch on some really important factors like Mileage , performance, comfort, safety etc. and have given their personal opinions about these cars.
Tata Punch has out rated MG Comet EV on all the rating factors.
Before making your decision you should also consider the unbiased and thorough analysis of these cars on every aspect by our auto experts who have summarised the analysis in pros, cons and final conclusion..

Ratings Factor Comet EV Punch
Mileage 2.5 3.5
Performance 2.4 3.9
Comfort 3.3 4.4
Maintenance 2.5 3.7
Safety 2.9 4.7
Features 3.7 4.3
Image
Do you own a Car or a Bike?
  • Interact with community
  • Become a Top Contributor
Add Car Add Bike

MG Comet EV Comparison with Similar Cars

Tata Punch Comparison with Similar Cars

Latest News on MG Motor Comet EV and Tata Punch

Recently Asked User Questions

Q. Which car is best between Punch and Exter?
  • Punch build quality is good
  • Both cars are good in their own forte. Tata Punch is good for city commutes but out on the highway, it lacks outright power which stops it from being versatile. Other than that it is hard to flaw this impressive car. It is spacious and comfortable, it is pretty well loaded and thanks to the option packs, even the lower variants can be customized to your requirements. On the other hand, the Exter knows its audience well and that makes the job easier for us. It gets a lot of things right, like the cabin experience, space, practicality, comfort, ease of drive, and boot space. And the features list is so good that it will be very hard to beat it in under Rs 10 lakh. The Hyundai Exter’s suspension balance is a sensible one. Given that it is going to spend most of its kilometres in the city, the suspension is set up on the softer side. We drove the Exter over bumpy roads, off the road and on the broken roads – and we can say that the suspension is very balanced. Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test ride before making the final decision. Follow the link and select your desired city for dealership details.
Q. Which is a better car, Tata Punch or Tata Tigor?
  • Both cars are good in their own forte. Tata Punch is good for city commutes but out on the highway, it lacks outright power which stops it from being versatile. Other than that it is hard to flaw this impressive car. It is spacious and comfortable, it is pretty well loaded and thanks to the option packs, even the lower variants can be customized to your requirements. On the other hand, If you are looking for a compact sedan with a brilliant safety package, impressive design, and a decent list of features, then you may opt for the Tata Tigor. Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test drive before making the final decision. Follow the link and select your desired city for details.
Q. Which is better Tata Punch or Tata Nexon?
  • Both cars are good in their own forte. The Nexon might feel a little rough around the edges if it's polished and the latest tech you're after. On the other hand, Tata Punch is good for city commutes but out on the highway, it lacks outright power which stops it from being versatile. Other than that it is hard to flaw this impressive car. It is spacious and comfortable, it is pretty well loaded and thanks to the option packs, even the lower variants can be customized to your requirements. Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test drive before making the final decision. Follow the link and select your desired city for dealershipdetails.
|MG Comet EV Community

MG Motor Comet EV Vs Tata Punch FAQs

Which car is best between MG Motor Comet EV vs Tata Punch?
Tata Punch has out rated MG Comet EV on all the rating factors.
Which car is cheaper MG Motor Comet EV vs Tata Punch?
The MG Comet EV is cheaper than Tata Punch by Rs. 50,100.
Which car offers better performance MG Motor Comet EV vs Tata Punch?
As per the users experiences the MG Comet EV has better performance.

Images of Tata Punch and MG Comet EV

Which one do you like more?
Comet EV
Comet EV
Punch
Punch
×
Select Category
✖
✖